A small neighborhood green and curving footpath beside newer traditional homes and autumn woodland in James City County, Virginia.

Where James City County's Next New Homes Will Actually Come From

On September 8, the James City County Board of Supervisors was set to hear Cardinal Ridge, D.R. Horton's plan for up to 1,066 homes and a commercial center on 365 acres of surplus Eastern State Hospital land off Ironbound Road. The plan never reached a vote. According to WHRO's report, the applicant withdrew it just before the public hearing, and the residents who had come to speak against it cheered when the board chair made the announcement.

Five weeks later the same thing happened to the other big proposal of the year. On October 13, the applicant for The Bluffs at Kiskiack withdrew its rezoning and special use permit applications, so the board took no action. The Bluffs was a 704-unit mixed-use plan off Croaker Road that included continuing care retirement homes and an open-air museum for the 42 presidents' heads from the old Presidents Park attraction, and the Daily Press reported in June that neither planning staff nor the Planning Commission had recommended it.

That takes about 1,700 proposed homes off the table for 2026. If you are comparing parts of James City County and hoping a new neighborhood will open near where you want to live, that matters. In this county, the new homes you can buy over the next several years were mostly approved years ago, and they sit in a handful of specific places.

What the Board Did Approve This Year

The projects that passed in 2026 were small, age-restricted, or both.

Westwood Park was approved 3–2 on July 14. It is about 80 acres of surplus Eastern State land next to New Town, reached from Discovery Park Boulevard, with 139 homes: 82 detached single-family houses and 57 townhomes and apartments, plus 24,000 square feet of commercial space. Williamsburg Watch called it a six-year process, during which the unit count went from 186 to 176 to 139. Twenty percent of the homes are set aside as affordable.

Ford's Village was approved 3–2 on May 12. It covers 177.5 acres off News Road and allows up to 270 age-restricted single-family and multifamily homes, plus up to 200 elder-care units: 154 independent-living apartments and 46 assisted-living, memory-care and skilled-nursing units, per the Daily Press. In February, supervisors also reapproved a permit for Forest Heights, a 50-unit senior living facility at 6015 Richmond Road that was first approved in 2019.

Taken together, that's 139 homes approved this year for buyers without an age requirement. They sit on one parcel by New Town, and even that approval took six years. Anyone hoping for a big new all-ages neighborhood to open in the county soon will be waiting a long time.

The 7,000 Homes Already Approved

The more useful number came from Supervisor Jim Icenhour, who voted against Westwood Park. According to Williamsburg Watch, he said he was concerned about adding to the roughly 7,000 homes the county has approved but that haven't been built yet. A week later, Williamsburg Watch mapped where those homes are, using the county's 2026 build-out map. The largest share is in the northern part of the county. The rest are scattered, including in long-established communities like Kingsmill and Ford's Colony.

Those already-approved homes, not this fall's withdrawn proposals, set what a buyer can choose from in the near term. The table below puts the approved-but-unbuilt counts from the 2026 map next to what Ryan Homes currently lists in James City County.

Community Area Approved homes not yet built, 2026 map What Ryan Homes lists now
Stonehouse Toano, north county 1,588 to 2,382 Stonehouse Townes from $309,990; Stonehouse Ranch, active adult, from $369,990; Stonehouse Estates from $459,990
The Settlement at Powhatan Creek Williamsburg side 100 to 200 Settlement at Powhatan 55+ villas from $359,990
Liberty Ridge Williamsburg address 70 to 102 Single-family from $849,990, 3,500+ sq. ft.
Summerplace Not specified Up to 164 Not listed

Ryan Homes shows quick move-in homes available at Stonehouse Estates and Settlement at Powhatan 55+. In the Stonehouse area that means a range of new options already on the ground, from townhomes starting near $310,000 to single-family homes starting near $460,000. Those prices come from the builder's current page and will change with plans and incentives.

Liberty Ridge is a different kind of product. It is a 139-lot subdivision first approved in 2006 in the county's rural lands, and a January 2025 county staff report counted about 64 lots recorded at that point. Its starting price of $849,990 is about 2.7 times the Stonehouse Townes starting price, for homes of 3,500-plus square feet on a rural setting.

What Buying in the Stonehouse Pipeline Looks Like

Since Stonehouse holds the largest share of the approved homes, most buyers who want new construction in James City County end up shopping there. Before you do, it helps to know how the community has changed. The county says a 2019 amendment cut about 1,100 homes from Stonehouse's maximum build-out. At a July town hall in Croaker, covered by the Daily Press, a Stonehouse resident said amenities in the original plan, including a 23-acre marina and five swimming pools, were dropped when the home count came down. My practical advice is to price a new home in Stonehouse against the amenities that exist today, not against an old master plan.

At the same meeting, VDOT said the Croaker Road widening won't be finished until November 2027. Residents also raised the community entrance at Fieldstone Parkway and Old Stage Road as an intersection that needs attention. If your commute runs through Croaker, plan on another year of construction. North county is also adding jobs. Kongsberg Defence & Aerospace told the town hall that construction would start this year on a 153,000-square-foot facility in Toano, a $70 million investment expected to bring 180 local jobs.

Meanwhile, the Resale Side Has More Choice

While new approvals have stalled, resale inventory has been growing. The Williamsburg Area Association of REALTORS' September 2026 report shows these James City County figures for September 2026 compared with September 2025:

Measure Sep 2025 Sep 2026 Change
New listings 176 199 +13.1%
Closed sales 133 156 +17.3%
Median sales price $535,000 $438,368 −18.1%
Active listings 435 540 +24.1%
Months of supply 3.3 4.0 +19.2%

The 18.1% median drop reflects one month of closings, and a single month's county median moves with the mix of homes that happened to close, as I covered in the earlier post on James City County's median price. The inventory numbers are more reliable. In September 2026 there were 540 active listings and four months of supply, compared with 435 listings and 3.3 months a year earlier, so buyers had noticeably more homes to choose from.

For a buyer comparing areas, that leaves two distinct markets. New construction over the next several years will be concentrated where the old approvals are, mainly Stonehouse in the north end, plus smaller remainders at Powhatan Creek, Liberty Ridge and Summerplace, with Westwood Park near New Town further out. Resale homes elsewhere in the county are on the market now in larger numbers than they were a year ago. If you want a new home close to New Town or Jamestown Road, the 2026 decisions mean you'll likely be buying resale there or waiting on Westwood Park. If you want new construction soon, most of what's available is in Toano.

Questions Buyers Ask

Are Cardinal Ridge or The Bluffs still in the pipeline? Both applications were withdrawn this fall, Cardinal Ridge on September 8 and The Bluffs on October 13, so neither is among the approved-but-unbuilt homes buyers can count on.

Is Westwood Park selling yet? The rezoning was approved July 14, 2026. Before you plan around a move-in date there, ask for a construction and sales timeline.

Why does Liberty Ridge cost so much more than Stonehouse? Ryan Homes lists Liberty Ridge homes starting at 3,500-plus square feet in a rural subdivision, while the Stonehouse options start at 1,628 square feet for townhomes. The two are different products serving different buyers.

If you're deciding between a Stonehouse new build and a resale closer to New Town, or wondering what the extra inventory means for your offer, I'm happy to walk through the specific homes with you, including how a builder's quick move-in compares with a lived-in house down the road. Get your instant home valuation or schedule a consultation with Berb at BERB Real Estate Partners.

Work With David

With decades of local expertise and trusted service, David Berberich “BERB” expertly guides you through buying or selling homes in Mechanicsville and beyond. Rely on him for personalized support and superior market insight.

Follow Me on Instagram